Evergreen Solar bankrupt….Solyndra bankrupt….Was it possible to see the collapse in the Solar stocks coming? Yes it was and I’ve mentioned this frequently for better for the better part of three years. It all boils down to the fact that you don’t want to own investments that rely heavily on government subsidies for their survival. You especially don’t want to own those investments during periods of financial austerity. The solar stock industry relies heavily upon subsidies from the US, China and Europe, with all three in either recession/depression or on the brink this outcome was inevitable.
For as long as I’ve been practicing SRI (over 20 years) I’ve been uniform and adamant that investing proactively is contradictory to effective long term investing. Investing including Socially Responsible Investing is about handling risk intelligently and dispensing with the rose colored glasses. Eventually every investment will turn against you and how you decide to cope with this inevitable turn will largely dictate the degree of your long term success. Being emotionally married to an investment is a sure and quick way to the poorhouse, you’d have been much better off supporting the company as a consumer not an investor.
Is there a survivor and a longer term winner in the bunch? Probably First Solar
Investing in Solar or Alternative energy now is nothing more than a spectator sport for the time being.
No positions.
With the disaster ongoing in the Gulf many people have asked me if this is a good time to invest in proactive Green energy. Can you imagine how badly I would like to say yes? But how do we weigh the desire to invest in Green Tech sensibly with a weak economy? With a tightrope of course and a strong balance sheet with a dirt cheap stock valuation as our net.
With this post I’d like to draw attention to the strong correlation to the price of oil (USO) which is driven primarily by economic growth and activity and the Powershares Wilderhill Clean Energy ETF (PBW) which I’m using as a proxy for Green Energy. At present we do not have the necessary worldwide GDP growth necessary for a price run in oil, especially with the world’s economic driver China attempting to cool its GDP growth, the present soft patch in the U.S. and the austerity measures in Europe.
The bottom line for the “Green Investor” is to look elsewhere for the time being. Look to other industries and companies that are not quite so cyclical and dependent upon fast GDP for growth. We must always keep in mind that “return of capital” is more important than “return on capital”.
Fear not, soon enough I’ll be writing on at least two very “Green” companies that meet our model of investment.
No Positions
Brad Pappas
Yesterdays rally confirmed our more constructive intermediate term outlook as the S&P 500 pushed above the 200 day moving average on a 90% up day. We have not seen a cluster of 90% up days since 2009 during the strongest points of the rally. Bears will comment that it was a fake rally due to high frequency trading, but as the coach of the New England Patriots Bill Belichick would drolly would say: “It is what it is”.
Yesterday while driving home I remembered a conversation from the mid 1990’s with a major SRI fund manager who insisted upon owning a major oil company despite their environmental screening policies. His rationale was that this particular company was the best of the lot, the most progressive within the space. Care to guess what that company was? Hint: my initials.
Being that I’m somewhat of a financial geek I get excited when our model identifies companies that are also identified as promising by other proven investment models. Case in point is IDT Corp. which also ranks very high on the esteemed
Piotroski model
as well as our own. We don’t own the stock for clients at present but will begin to look closely at it.
Also, will be breaking down a host of Green Tech firms looking for revenue acceleration. Stories about this morning about the promise of Green Tech but unless revenues start to move higher its only a trade and not an investment.
All the best,
BP
